No. In California, an insurance company cannot require you to have your car repaired at a specific auto body shop. You may choose the registered shop that will do the work, including Visalia Auto Body, even if your insurer has a preferred or “direct repair” list. This article is general information about that choice, not legal advice.
Can my insurer still recommend a shop?
Yes, but California law sets conditions on those recommendations. According to the California Department of Insurance’s summary of Insurance Code section 758.5, an insurer may recommend a specific shop if you ask for a recommendation, or if you have been told in writing that you have the right to choose your own shop. If you accept a recommended shop, the insurer must restore the vehicle to its condition before the loss, with no added cost to you other than what your policy or the law already allows. If the recommendation is made over the phone and you accept it, the insurer must follow up with a required written notice.
An insurer may also share factual information about warranties, parts, expected repair time, and workmanship. After you have chosen a shop, the insurer generally may not steer you to a different one, except in the limited situations the statute describes.
If you want the official wording, read Insurance Code section 758.5 and the Department of Insurance guide “So You’ve Had an Accident, What’s Next?”.
What if I choose my own shop?
Choosing your own shop does not cancel a covered claim. The Department of Insurance states that if the vehicle is repaired at a shop you select, the insurance company must pay the reasonable cost to repair the vehicle in accordance with accepted trade standards for good and workmanlike automotive repairs. The insurer is also prohibited from limiting or discounting those reasonable repair costs based on what the work would have cost at the company’s recommended shop.
California’s Auto Body Repair Consumer Bill of Rights, which insurers are required to provide under 10 CCR section 2695.85, states that you are entitled to:
- Select the auto body repair shop that will repair damage covered by the insurance company
- An itemized written estimate, and a detailed invoice when the work is finished, with parts identified as new, used, aftermarket, reconditioned, or rebuilt
- Information about coverage for towing, storage, and a rental vehicle, if any
- An independent repair estimate from a registered auto body shop, even while you are pursuing an insurance claim
Those rules come from the state, not from Visalia Auto Body. For questions about how your own policy is being handled, contact your insurer or the California Department of Insurance.
Can I use Visalia Auto Body if I am not with a preferred program?
Yes. Visalia Auto Body works with all insurance companies. Customers who are with any insurer, and customers paying out of pocket, are welcome.
If you have been in a collision, start with a free estimate. The staff will walk you through the estimate, the insurance claim, and the collision repair.
What should I do before repairs begin?
In California, a registered auto shop must give you a written estimate for parts and labor before work starts, and you must authorize the work. If additional damage is found after the job begins, the shop must contact you and get authorization before proceeding. When the repair is finished, you should receive a detailed invoice. The Bureau of Automotive Repair explains these requirements in its consumer auto repair guidance.
Before you sign anything, it helps to:
- Confirm that you — not the insurer alone — have chosen the shop
- Read the itemized estimate, including how each part is described
- Ask how safety-system (ADAS) calibration will be handled if cameras or sensors were affected
- Ask your insurer what, if any, rental, towing, or storage coverage applies to your policy
Frequently asked questions
Do I have to use the shop my insurance company recommends?
No. California law does not allow an insurer to require a specific auto body shop. You may choose a registered shop, including Visalia Auto Body. An insurer may recommend a shop only under the conditions described in Insurance Code section 758.5. This is general information, not legal advice.
Will Visalia Auto Body work with my insurance company?
Yes. Visalia Auto Body works with all insurance companies. Out-of-pocket repairs are welcome too.
Can I get an estimate from Visalia Auto Body even if I already have an insurer’s estimate?
Yes. California’s Auto Body Repair Consumer Bill of Rights says you may seek an independent estimate from a registered auto body shop even while you are pursuing an insurance claim. Call 559-734-4115, stop by the shop, or use the estimate form on the contact page. Estimates are free.
What if my insurer and the shop’s estimate do not match?
Differences sometimes appear after a closer inspection or a teardown reveals hidden damage. California shops must get your authorization before adding work, and insurers have their own fair-claims rules for reviewing estimates. Visalia Auto Body will walk you through the claim and the revised estimate. For a dispute about how a claim is handled, you can also contact the California Department of Insurance.
Talk with the shop
If you want Visalia Auto Body to handle the repair, call 559-734-4115, visit the shop at 601 E. Acequia Ave., Visalia, CA 93292, or request a free estimate on the contact page. The team will work with your insurance company from the first estimate to the final repair.